基础法律英语辅导热招
您的位置:外语教育网 > 法律英语 > 法治资讯 > 正文

Supreme Court Refuses Review in BlackBerry Patent Dispute

2006-01-24 00:00   我要纠错 | 打印 | 收藏 | | |

  By IAN AUSTEN

  OTTAWA, Jan. 23 - The United States Supreme Court on Monday rejected a bid by Research in Motion, the Canadian maker of BlackBerry e-mail devices, to review its patent dispute with the holding company NTP.

  The court's decision means that the case is now back in the hands of Judge James R. Spencer of Federal District Court in Richmond, Va. He is considering a request from NTP to impose an injunction banning the sale and use of most BlackBerry hand-held devices in the United States.

  An injunction could come as soon as next month. It is possible that the two companies could reach an out-of-court settlement before then, which they have tried but failed to do in the past. R.I.M. is also trying to overturn NTP's patent claims through a separate United States patent office review.

  R.I.M. has acknowledged that the Supreme Court rarely hears patent cases. The company had hoped, however, that the justices would explore its argument that the wireless e-mail patents held by NTP, an intellectual property holding company based in Arlington, Va., did not extend beyond the borders of the United States.

  In its court submissions, R.I.M. said that the software at the heart of the dispute exists only on servers near its headquarters in Waterloo, Ontario. Because NTP does not hold any patents in Canada, R.I.M. argued that the company had no valid claim on the BlackBerry.

  "We're happy that the Supreme Court rejected R.I.M.'s efforts to create a huge loophole in the patent law," Kevin Anderson, a lawyer for NTP, said.

  In an e-mail message, Mark Guibert, R.I.M.'s vice president for corporate marketing, said that the company still believed that it had several options to block the injunction as well as the imposition of the terms of NTP's court victory in 2002. In that ruling, the federal court issued an injunction banning BlackBerry sales in the United States, but stayed the injunction pending the outcome of the appeal. It also ordered R.I.M. to pay NTP millions in royalties. There are now no further avenues for R.I.M. to appeal that ruling.

  "The patent office continues its re-examinations with special dispatch," Mr. Guibert wrote., "R.I.M.'s legal arguments for the district court remain strong and our software workaround designs remain a solid contingency." While it has not offered full details, R.I.M. has said that it has prepared a workaround - an alternative BlackBerry system - that it believes does not violate NTP's patents.

  NTP has asked Judge Spencer to impose an injunction he granted in 2002 but suspended to permit R.I.M.'s appeals. The court is expected to announce a hearing date for NTP's case as early as this week.

  At R.I.M.'s request, the United States Patent and Trademark Office is reviewing NTP's claims. It has said that it expects to issue a final ruling rejecting all of them. NTP will still have two avenues of appeal for that decision. It is not clear, though, how Judge Spencer would respond to any action by the patent office.

相关资讯:
网站导航:
 四六级 指南 动态 经验 试题 资料  托福 指南 动态 经验 留学 备考
 雅思 指南 动态 机经 经验 辅导  公共英语 指南 动态 备考 试题 辅导
 日语 就业 辅导 留学 考试 报考  法语 资料 文化 考试 留学 辅导
 韩语 入门 口语 阅读 留学 文化  西语 辅导 资料 考试 留学 风采
基础法律英语
350元/门
系统讲解知识,全面提升水平
课时数:18课时左右

外语教育网(www.for68.com)是北京东大正保科技有限公司(CDEL)旗下一家大型外语远程教育网站,正保科技成立于2005年7月,是国内超大型外语远程教育基地,上榜“北京优质教育资源榜”--“百万读者推崇的网络教育机构”。


公司凭借雄厚的师资力量、先进的网络视频多媒体课件技术、严谨细致的教学作风、灵活多样的教学方式,为学员提供完整、优化的外语课程,既打破了传统面授的诸多限制,发挥了网络教育的优势,也兼顾面授的答疑与互动特点,为我国培养了大量优秀的外语人才。


为了满足学员学习不同语种、不同阶段的学习需求,网站开设了包括考试英语、行业英语、实用口语以及小语种在内的百余门语言学习课程,涵盖英语、日语、韩语、俄语、德语、法语、西班牙语、意大利语、阿拉伯语等主要语种,供学员自由选择。此外,网站还拥有各类外语专业信息和考试信息20余万条,是广大学员了解外语类考试最新政策、动态及参加各语种培训的优质网站。


北京东大正保科技有限公司成立于2000年,是一家具备网络教育资质、经教育部批准开展远程教育的专业公司,为北京市高新技术企业、中国十大教育集团、联合国教科文组织技术与职业教育培训在中国的唯一试点项目。


公司下属13家行业远程教育网站,业务涵盖了会计、法律、医学、建设、自考、成考、考研、中小学、外语、信息技术、汉语言教学等诸多领域,拥有办公面积8000多平米,员工近千人,公司年招生规模达270万人。由于正保远程教育(China Distance Education Holdings Ltd., CDEL)在中国互联网远程教育行业内的绝对优势和强大影响力,正保教育模式一直被广大投资人所追捧。2008年7月30日,公司在美国纽约证券交易所正式挂牌上市(股票交易代码:DL),是2008年唯一一家在美国纽交所上市的专业从事互联网远程教育的中国企业。


版权声明
   1、凡本网注明 “来源:外语教育网”的所有作品,版权均属外语教育网所有,未经本网授权不得转载、链接、转贴或以其他方式使用;已经本网授权的,应在授权范围内使用,且必须注明“来源:外语教育网”。违反上述声明者,本网将追究其法律责任。
  2、本网部分资料为网上搜集转载,均尽力标明作者和出处。对于本网刊载作品涉及版权等问题的,请作者与本网站联系,本网站核实确认后会尽快予以处理。
  本网转载之作品,并不意味着认同该作品的观点或真实性。如其他媒体、网站或个人转载使用,请与著作权人联系,并自负法律责任。
  3、本网站欢迎积极投稿
  4、联系方式:
编辑信箱:for68@chinaacc.com
电话:010-82319999-2371